| |
Class Notes for 07-221
Justifying Religious Beliefs
University of Windsor
Fall
Semester, 2006
Dr. B. L. Whitney, B.A., Ph.D.
Last revised: Dec 12, 2006
FINAL
EXAM PREPARATION:
Besides the information given in lecture
notes, the follow
lists assigned readings to be prepared for the Final Exam:
the focus is on the final section, but there are a few overheads
and basic sections of Kreeft's Handbook (chapters 1 and
2) from the first two sections of the course. The
final exam will contain about 60 multiple choice questions; the
time allowed will be 60 minutes. There are some basic questions
(1 page), questions about the assigned overheads: #11-19 (1.5
pages), questions from Kreeft, ch 1 and ch 2: see assigned pages
in Kreeft below (.5 pages), questions about Miracles (Kreeft,
ch 5 and web documents), the resurrection miracle and the miracle
of fulfilled prophesy (3.5 pages).
Items from the
first two parts of the couse
1. BASICS RE: JUSTIFYING RELIGIOUS BELIEFS
*OVERHEADS:
The need to justify religious beliefs (Overheads, set 1, numbers
17-19)
*OVERHEADS: Three approaches to justifying beliefs: Faithism,
etc. (Overheads 11-16)
*KREEFT, Handbook, chapter 1, pages
20-21: response to criticisms that justifiying beliefs is
unnecessary or impossible
*KREEFT,
Handbook, chapter 1, pages 21-24: reasons why we need to justify
beliefs
*KREEFT, Handbook, chapter 2: pages 41-43: response to criticisms
that justifiying beliefs is unnecessary or impossible
Items from the third
part of the course: Justifying Beliefs in Miracles, including
the Resurrection Miracle and the Fulfilled Prophesy Miracles
2. MIRACLES: Kreeft's 17 refutation of
criticism and the Catholic Church's Testing of Miracles
*KREEFT, Handbook, chapter 5, pages 109-114: Kreeft's
refututions of 5 criticisms against the possibility of miracles
*KREEFT, web
document: Kreeft's refutations of 12 criticisms against
the possibility of miracles
*NOXA: web
document: limited to the points noted in class:
discussion of the testing criteria for alleged miracles by
the Catholic Church
3. MIRACLE OF FULFILLED PROPHESY BY JESUS
*CARM, web document: examples of some of the fulfilled prophesies of Jesus as evidence of miraculous intervention by God
4. MIRACLE OF JESUS'
RESURRECTION *KREEFT, Handbook, chapter 8: Kreeft's arguments in support
of belief in the resurrection and his refutation of criticisms
of the the miracle of Jesus' resurrection
*KEATHLEY, web
document:
evidence for the reality of Jesus' resurrection
*KREEFT, Handbook,
pages 189-195:
Arguments against the mistaken view that the New Testament's
account of Jesus is "myth" (note: there are 6 points listed:
do not worry about the details re: point 6 on pages 193-195
For all these readings, make a list of
the main points and focus on them without being distracted by
complex details: some of these reasings were not discussed in
detail in class: you task is to make the summaries of the main
points.
The Bible is justified as trustworthy by
the following evidence -- just a brief part of
many other evidences which are too complex and numerous
to list here or to have discussed in class: The
main point is that the Bible is not myth, nor was
it written many decades after the fact. Kreeft's book (pages
189-195 and 161-165) gives evidence for this. Other evidence
is found in the fact that Paul's letters in the New Testament
quote early hymns and creeds from the 30s and 40s AD, the
time directly after Jesus death and resurrection: these early
hymns and creeds refer to Jesus as Lord, God, and as worshipped;
they show belief also in his resurrection from
the dead: the point is that these beliefs
did not come 100 yeas later from the church when all of the
eye-witnesses were gone. They were the beliefs of the eye-witnesses. Another
amazing piece of evidence is that the early Church leaders
cited over 36,000 references to the New Testament between
95 and 250AD, citing all ut the two minor letters of John.
The New Testament texts they cited
is exactly the same Bible we have now; the point here again
is that the original eye-witness accounts which are in the
New Testament were not made up later, as liberal scholars
like to think. There is also the
testimony about Jesus from non-Christian writers in the first
century: they speak of Jesus being worshipped as God, his
resurrection, and the quick spread of Christianity. These
external references (external to the New Testament) are supported
by internal evidences, including
Jesus' unique life (virgin birth,
miracles, resurrection, the amazing 371 fulfilled prophesies
which confirmed He was Messiah, the suffering deity whose
sacrifice paid the price for human sin, as well as his teaching
and actions which showed He was indeed God in the flesh (details
for this were not given in class and readings are not assigned
since there are so many points: some can be found at the
end of Kreeft, pages 173-174). Another external evidence
for the Bible's trustworthiness is the
confirmation by Archaeology of
the accuracy of the New Testament about cities, public figures,
geography and social conditions: Luke, for example, who wrote
one of the 4 Gospels and The Acts of the
Apostles, mentioned 32 countries, 54 cities, 9 islands and
countless geographical and social facts which have been confirmed
by archaeology. This is strong evidence that he was seeking
to be accurate and truthful, rather than writing myth about
Jesus and the early church. Non-Christian texts, Early Church
Fathers and other documents confirm the early dating
of the New Testament -- that is, the fact that it was ritten
by eye-witnesses or those who knew the eye-witnesses within
20-50 years of Jesus life. Check the CARM and Fernandes web
documents fir details about this. Luke's Book of Acts was
likely written about 60-62 AD, Luke's Gospel just before
that, about 60AD (since Acts is part two of Luke's writings
his Gospel being part one); since Luke used parts of Mark's
Gospel, it was written before Luke, in the 50s or earlier,
and Matthew's Gospel which also uses parts of Mark's has
traditionally been cited as very early (by Papias) and written
first in Aramaic, the language of Jesus and the Christians
before 50AD, etc. Paul's letters, of course, are acknowledged
by scholars as written between 48 and 64 AD, and he takes
for granted Jesus is
the Christ (mentioned 270 times) and that he rose from the
dead and was God in the flesh, the son of God. This early
testimony could have been refuted if eye-witnesses who were
still alive if it was not true. Kree
ft's book, chapters 7 and 9 are the major resources for this,
along with the web documents on the class web page.
I hope you will check
(after the class is over) Kreeft's justification
of belief in an afterlife, and in Heaven
and Hell (chapters 10-12).
And I hope you will continue during your lives to give time
for the ongoing quest to seek information and evidence which
helps justify your religious beliefs. This leads to a deeper
spirituality, a reasonable faith rather than blind faith.
It has been a great joy for me to have
had the privilege to teach this class to such a wonderful
group of students. Thank you all. Dr BW
|
|